I am celebrating today. The more I read about the change in immigration policy that President Obama announced yesterday, the more
I like it. It's a good move. It's the right move. While I do not
doubt that the change, or at least the timing of it, was politically
calculated, that doesn't make it wrong. It simply makes President
Obama an astute politician.
My enthusiasm for this positive change
is tempered only by the strong negative reaction I hear from so many.
I must confess that I do not understand those who oppose this move.
The opposition seems to derive from a mindset that views strict
enforcement of laws over basic humanitarian principles. But I think
that such a response to this change in policy really demonstrates the
values of God's kingdom. Those affected by this new policy did not
choose to break the laws of our country, so to say they must bear the
full penalty for doing so seems to me extreme and unnecessary. It
says that justice triumphs over mercy, which is not how I read it in
my Bible.
The people who will benefit directly
from this policy are in all significant ways Americans already. They
may lack the official documents of residency and citizenship, but
they have grown up here and identify this place as their home, not
Mexico or some other country from which they came years ago. Sending
them back to a place they don't really know, whose language and
culture are in fact foreign to them, is cruel and unjust.
Furthermore, the policy supports those who have the potential to
contribute to the United States. They have received or are receiving
an education here. Some have served in our armed forces. Deporting
them robs our country of valuable members of society. These young
people contribute to society, not take from it. In a newspaper article I read this morning, one young local woman of Mexican origin
said:
“We want to give back. We're not here
just to take, we want to give back to this nation...be leaders, great
leaders who inspire others.”
The same young woman also stated:
“I was raised here, my culture (is)
here. I wouldn't call (Mexico) home.”
The largely partisan objections to
President Obama's announcement ignore the reality of the individuals
who will benefit from this change. They focus on the politics of the
decision, ignoring the roadblocks Republicans have put in the way of
enacting similar legislation in Congress as well as the fact that the
policy change Obama has implemented comes largely from a proposal by
a Republican congressman. Apparently if Obama adopts an idea
originally promoted by Republicans, the idea suddenly becomes toxic.
Those who object to this change also seem to see the world in black
and white. You're either an illegal immigrant or you're not. If you
are, you're a criminal and a drain on American society and the only
suitable and appropriate way to treat you is to get you out of our
country as fast as possible. There's no middle ground, no recognition
that many cases are not so clear-cut. It's a false dichotomy and it's
a wrong, unhelpful approach, especially since it affects the lives of
real individuals.
This change in immigration policy is a
sensible, humanitarian response to a difficult situation. It is not
the final solution, but it is a positive step. I celebrate this as a
small victory in the effort to adopt a more open, inclusive
immigration policy, as I have written about over the last few days
(here and here). If those who oppose this change would adopt a more
cooperative, constructive approach to resolving immigration issues,
the president would not be compelled to accomplish positive change
through presidential decree. But until that day, I'll gladly welcome
such small steps as can be taken.
No comments:
Post a Comment